Legal Structures in CARICOM

Purpose

This page helps business founders understand and evaluate legal structure options available across CARICOM member states. It provides a decision framework for selecting an appropriate entity type based on liability, tax, operational, and compliance considerations.

The guidance focuses on concepts and trade-offs rather than country-specific implementation details. It is intended for startups and SMBs planning to establish operations in one or more CARICOM jurisdictions.

Context & Assumptions

Regional Variability

While CARICOM countries share common legal concepts (largely derived from English common law traditions), specific entity requirements, naming conventions, and procedures vary significantly. This guidance outlines common principles; always verify specific requirements with authorities in your target jurisdiction.

Business Size Focus

Targeted at startups and small to medium-sized businesses
Excludes specialized structures (e.g., trusts, foundations, specialized investment vehicles)
Assumes commercial trading activities; regulated sectors (financial services, insurance, telecommunications) may have additional requirements

Technical Baseline

Readers should understand:

Basic corporate structure concepts (shareholders, directors, liability)
Tax fundamentals (corporate income tax, VAT, withholding taxes)
Cross-border business basics (treaties, currency exchange, compliance obligations)

Core Guidance

Common Entity Types Across CARICOM

Sole Proprietorship (Sole Trader)

Structure: Unincorporated business owned and operated by one individual.

Characteristics:

Simplest formation process
No separate legal entity from the owner
Unlimited personal liability for business debts and obligations
Business income taxed as personal income
Least expensive to establish and maintain
Limited credibility with larger clients and partners

Appropriate When:

Testing business concept with minimal capital risk
Operating low-liability service business
Seeking minimal administrative overhead
Planning eventual transition to incorporated structure

Trade-offs: Lower cost and simplicity versus unlimited personal liability and limited growth potential.

Limited Liability Company / Private Limited Company

Structure: Separate legal entity with shareholders, directors, and limited liability protection.

Characteristics:

Separate legal personality from owners
Shareholder liability typically limited to capital contribution
Corporate income tax applies at entity level
More complex formation and ongoing compliance
Enhanced credibility with clients, partners, and financial institutions
Facilitates ownership transfer and capital raising

Appropriate When:

Business involves significant liability exposure
Planning to hire employees or contract with third parties
Seeking investment or financing from institutional sources
Intending long-term operations or eventual sale
Requiring separate legal identity for contracts and ownership

Trade-offs: Liability protection and credibility versus higher cost and administrative complexity.

Partnership (General or Limited)

Structure: Business owned by two or more parties under partnership agreement.

Characteristics:

General Partnership: All partners share liability, management, and profits according to agreement
Limited Partnership: Includes general partners (full liability) and limited partners (liability limited to contribution)
Partnership agreement governs relationship, profit sharing, and dispute resolution
Tax treatment varies; often flow-through taxation to partners
Moderate formation cost and complexity

Appropriate When:

Multiple founders bringing complementary skills or capital
Sharing operational responsibility and decision-making
Leveraging combined expertise or market access
Seeking flexibility in profit and loss allocation

Trade-offs: Shared control and risk versus individual autonomy; requires strong partnership governance.

Branch Office

Structure: Extension of foreign parent company operating in local jurisdiction.

Characteristics:

Not a separate legal entity; parent company retains full liability
Requires registration as foreign entity
Profits may be repatriated to parent subject to withholding tax
Parent company financial statements may be required
Simpler than forming subsidiary but exposes parent to liability

Appropriate When:

Testing market before full incorporation
Parent company has adequate liability protection
Local entity formation is temporarily impractical
Regulatory framework permits branch operations in your sector

Trade-offs: Faster establishment versus parent company liability exposure.

Representative Office

Structure: Non-commercial presence for market research, liaison, and relationship development.

Characteristics:

Cannot engage in revenue-generating activities
Minimal regulatory requirements and costs
Limited scope of permitted activities
Typically requires transition to commercial entity for actual operations

Appropriate When:

Conducting pre-market research and feasibility studies
Establishing relationships before full market entry
Coordinating activities without direct commercial transactions
Regulatory approval for full operations is pending

Trade-offs: Low cost and quick setup versus inability to generate revenue or conduct commercial activities.

Selection Framework

Liability Considerations

Risk Assessment:

Nature of business activities and associated liability exposure
Asset protection requirements for founders
Contractual liability and third-party claims potential
Professional indemnity and insurance availability and cost

Decision Criteria: High-liability businesses (manufacturing, construction, professional services with client assets) typically require limited liability structures. Low-liability businesses (consulting, digital services) may function as sole proprietorships or partnerships with adequate insurance.

Tax Implications

Entity-Level Taxation:

Corporate structures pay entity-level tax then withholding tax on dividends
Sole proprietorships and partnerships may have flow-through taxation
Branch offices may face different withholding treatment than subsidiaries
Consider both domestic tax rates and treaty benefits for repatriation

Decision Criteria: Evaluate combined tax burden including entity tax, withholding tax, and any applicable treaty relief. Model tax scenarios across multiple years to account for profitability changes and dividend distribution timing.

Operational Requirements

Formation and Maintenance Costs:

Government registration fees
Legal and professional service costs
Ongoing compliance costs (annual returns, accounting, audits)
Time to establishment

Administrative Burden:

Director and shareholder meeting requirements
Annual filing obligations
Statutory record-keeping
Professional service provider requirements (resident agent, company secretary)

Decision Criteria: Balance compliance cost against liability protection, tax benefits, and operational credibility. Startups with limited capital may initially choose simpler structures with planned future transition to incorporated entities.

Cross-Border Considerations

Multi-Jurisdiction Operations:

Will you operate in multiple CARICOM countries?
Should you establish separate entities or branches?
Where should regional holding company be located?
How will you coordinate compliance across jurisdictions?

Banking and Payments:

Banking relationship requirements in each jurisdiction
Payment processing and foreign exchange considerations
Regulatory approval for cross-border fund transfers
Anti-money laundering and know-your-customer documentation

Decision Criteria: Multi-jurisdiction strategies may benefit from regional holding company structure to centralize management and optimize treaty benefits. Single-country operations typically use local entity formation unless branch structure is strategically preferable.

CARICOM-Specific Considerations

CARICOM Single Market and Economy (CSME)

The CSME aims to facilitate free movement of goods, services, capital, and qualified labor across member states. However, implementation is partial and uneven:

Business establishment procedures still vary significantly by country
Professional qualification recognition exists for certain categories but requires certification
Work permit requirements persist even for CARICOM nationals in many categories
Tax harmonization is incomplete; bilateral treaties govern most cross-border tax issues

Practical Impact: Do not assume CSME eliminates country-specific formation, licensing, or compliance requirements. Verify specific procedures in each target jurisdiction.

Treaty Networks

Several CARICOM countries maintain extensive double taxation treaty networks that can provide significant benefits for regional operations:

Reduced withholding tax on dividends, interest, and royalties
Tax credit mechanisms to avoid double taxation
Permanent establishment definitions affecting branch vs. subsidiary choices
Information exchange agreements affecting compliance obligations

Practical Impact: Treaty benefits significantly influence jurisdiction and structure selection for multi-country operations. Engage qualified tax advisors to model treaty implications.

Common Pitfalls

Incorrect Liability Assessment

Founders frequently underestimate liability exposure, particularly for:

Professional services where client assets or decisions are affected
Products with quality or safety implications
Services involving third-party contractors or subcontractors
Cross-border operations where multiple legal systems apply

Consequence: Personal asset exposure in sole proprietorships or partnerships when claims arise.

Mitigation: Conduct thorough risk assessment; choose limited liability structures when exposure is material; maintain adequate insurance coverage.

Tax Structure Oversights

Common tax planning mistakes include:

Failing to model combined entity tax and withholding tax burden
Ignoring treaty benefits that could reduce overall tax cost
Not considering transfer pricing implications for related-party transactions
Underestimating ongoing tax compliance costs in multiple jurisdictions

Consequence: Higher-than-necessary tax burden; potential disputes with tax authorities; unexpected compliance costs.

Mitigation: Engage qualified tax advisors in both home and target jurisdictions before entity formation; model multiple scenarios including profit distribution timing.

Uniformity Assumptions

Assuming CARICOM countries have identical entity requirements leads to:

Wrong entity type selection for specific jurisdictions
Missing required documentation or authentication
Non-compliance with local director, secretary, or agent requirements
Delayed registration due to incomplete applications

Consequence: Formation delays; increased professional service costs for corrections; potential rejection of applications.

Mitigation: Verify specific requirements in target jurisdiction before preparing formation documents; engage local counsel for jurisdiction-specific guidance.

Inadequate Partnership Governance

Partnerships formed without comprehensive written agreements encounter:

Disputes over profit distribution and loss allocation
Conflicts regarding decision-making authority
Disagreements about partner withdrawal or admission
Ambiguity regarding liability allocation

Consequence: Business disruption; costly disputes; potential dissolution; personal relationship damage.

Mitigation: Execute detailed partnership agreement drafted by qualified counsel covering all material governance, financial, and exit scenarios before commencing operations.

Parent Liability in Branch Structures

Using branch offices without recognizing parent liability implications:

Parent company assets exposed to claims in branch jurisdiction
Parent company financial disclosure may be required
Credit and contractual obligations become parent obligations
Regulatory actions may affect parent company

Consequence: Unexpected exposure of parent company assets; potential claims against parent in home jurisdiction; reputational risk.

Mitigation: Conduct thorough legal review of parent liability implications; maintain adequate insurance; consider subsidiary structure if exposure is material.

Legal Structures in CARICOM

Purpose

Context & Assumptions

Regional Variability

Business Size Focus

Technical Baseline

Core Guidance

Common Entity Types Across CARICOM

Sole Proprietorship (Sole Trader)

Limited Liability Company / Private Limited Company

Partnership (General or Limited)

Branch Office

Representative Office

Selection Framework

Liability Considerations

Tax Implications

Operational Requirements

Cross-Border Considerations

CARICOM-Specific Considerations

CARICOM Single Market and Economy (CSME)

Treaty Networks

Common Pitfalls

Incorrect Liability Assessment

Tax Structure Oversights

Uniformity Assumptions

Inadequate Partnership Governance

Parent Liability in Branch Structures

Related Documentation